< Back

Difficult Clients and AI-Assisted Claims: Risk Prevention Tips for Ohio Lawyers

Post on November 5th, 2026

As AI tools make it easier for dissatisfied and difficult clients to pursue malpractice claims, familiar loss prevention practices are more important than ever. Learn how careful client selection, clear expectations, and thorough documentation can reduce risk before disputes arise.

When a dissatisfied or difficult client can produce a lengthy, polished malpractice complaint with an AI tool, even a weak claim can consume time and resources. Careful client selection, realistic expectations, contemporaneous documentation, and a deliberate exit strategy can help prevent the dispute or strengthen the lawyer’s defense. 

OBLIC has experienced a significant increase in malpractice claims asserted by pro se litigants in 2026. More than 50% of new claims are now asserted by pro se claimants, compared with approximately 25% in 2025 and 10% in 2024. Similarities among some complaints suggest the use of AI-assisted drafting, although their use has not been independently established.  

While these claims may lack a viable legal basis, the underlying representations often share a commonality: a difficult attorney-client relationship. AI may change how easily a dissatisfied client can prepare a claim, but the most effective risk-management strategies remain familiar ones. Preventing a difficult-client claim begins before the engagement. 

Screen the client as carefully as the matter 

Before accepting a matter, confirm that it falls within an area in which you are competent to practice. A client’s persistence is not a reason to accept a matter beyond your experience or capabilities. 

Complete an appropriate conflict check before receiving unnecessary confidential information. Then listen carefully. Determine whether the prospective client has a legal problem you can address, whether the law offers a realistic remedy, and whether the client will accept candid advice about likely outcomes.

Unreasonable expectations, hostility toward prior counsel, resistance to unwelcome advice, or demands for a particular result may signal that the relationship will become unmanageable. Pay attention to what the prospective client is telling you, including how they respond when your assessment differs from their expectations. 

Define the engagement and set expectations in writing 

If you accept the matter, use a written fee agreement that clearly identifies:

  • The scope and limits of the representation; 
  • The fee and billing arrangements; 
  • The client’s responsibilities, including honesty, cooperation, and payment; and 
  • How and when the lawyer and client will communicate. 

Discuss realistic outcomes at the outset, including potential costs, limitations, and uncertainties. A clear engagement letter cannot eliminate every disagreement, but it can reduce later disputes over what the lawyer agreed to do. 

The Supreme Court of Ohio’s A Consumer’s Practical Guide to Managing a Relationship With a Lawyer is an useful resource to share with clients. Its discussion of client responsibilities can help reinforce expectations established at the beginning of the outset. Especially difficult clients may be directed to the Duties of a Client in this official court publication. 

Document consequential advice and client decisions  

Document important advice, material risks, available alternatives, and significant client decisions contemporaneously. When a client rejects a recommended course of action, confirm in writing the recommendation, the consequences discussed, and the direction the client has chosen.  

A written acknowledgement can establish that the client understood the advice and made an informed decision. It does not, however, relieve the lawyer of professional obligations or establish that the client’s preferred course is legally or ethically appropriate. Nor should it be used to circumvent Ohio Prof. Conduct R. 1.8(h), which restricts agreements prospectively limiting a lawyer’s malpractice liability.

Billing problems can also provide early warning. Establish a billing schedule, send invoices consistently, and address nonpayment and objections promptly rather than allowing the dispute to accumulate. 

Withdraw carefully when the relationship becomes unworkable 

If continued representation is no longer appropriate, evaluate whether withdrawal is permissible or necessary under Ohio Prof. Conduct Rule 1.16 and any applicable court rules.  Rule 1.16(b)(6) permits withdrawal when representation has been rendered unreasonably difficult by the client, but the decision requires carful consideration of the client’s interests and the lawyer’s continuing obligations.  

When tribunal permission is required, review the applicable local rules and draft the motion with Rule 1.6 confidentiality obligations in mind. Rule 1.6 generally prohibits disclosure of information relating to the representation unless an identified exception applies. Avoid unnecessarily revealing confidential communications or making statements adverse to the client. See Columbus Bar Association v Burgess, 2021-Ohio-375 (Board Case No. 2020-043). Also review the Local Rules of Court.

Once withdrawal is properly complete, avoid re-entering the representation. A decision to resume representation can recreate the same problems that led to withdrawal. 

Close the file as deliberately as you opened it  

Confirm in writing that the representation has ended. Take reasonable steps to protect the client’s interests, including providing appropriate notice, allowing time to obtain other counsel, returning client papers and property as required, and refunding any unearned fees as required by R. 1.16(d).

Document delivery of original documents, retain appropriate copies, and follow the firm’s file-retention procedures.  Preserve the engagement agreement, important communications, advice, client decisions, billing history, withdrawal documents, and closing letter. See sample File Closing Letter.  

Consider what a defense lawyer would need if a malpractice claim or disciplinary grievance arrived months or years later. A complete, well-organized file can be critical to establishing what occurred during the representation. 

Prevention remains the best defense 

AI-assisted drafting may make it easier for dissatisfied clients to assert claims, but it does not change the lawyer’s underlying professional obligations. Careful client selection, realistic expectations, clear documentation, timely withdrawal when appropriate and deliberate file closure remain essential safeguards. 

OBLIC policyholders facing a difficult client, possible withdrawal, or another loss-prevention concern should contact OBLIC’s Loss Prevention team for assistance. We are here to help. 

Gretchen K. Mote, Esq.
Director of Loss Prevention
Direct:  614.572.0620

gmote@oblic.com
Merisa K. Bowers, Esq.
Director of Marketing and
Loss Prevention Counsel

Direct:  614.859.2978
mbowers@oblic.com

This information is made available solely for loss prevention purposes, which may include claim prevention techniques designed to minimize the likelihood of incurring a claim for legal malpractice. This information does not establish, report, or create the standard of care for attorneys. The material is not a complete analysis of the topic and should not be construed as providing legal advice. Please conduct your own appropriate legal research in this area. If you have questions about this email’s content and are an OBLIC policyholder, please contact us using the information above.